Friday, February 12, 2010

Week 3 - Useful Concept

A concept I enjoyed reading, although short, was the paragraph on criticizing the pragmatic model. It follows too closely to the systems theory, which I learned in Comm144, Organization Communication which I took a couple of semesters ago. Systems Theory in a paraphrased definition states that every (person) is part of a machine and in order for that machine to operate correctly, each part of the machine needs to do its part. If there is a weak part or a part that is not fully operating correctly in the machine then the machine falls apart. This theory looks at people as things and basically have a linear look on what people can and cannot do. It is so old fashion and closed minded, it is mind-boggling to know there are people who still think that way when it comes to people.I enjoyed reading that small paragraph because everything that it had stated was exactly almost what I wrote in my second question and also mirrors my true feelings on the subject. The pragmatic model and systems theory belong to a communist country, which we are not. (No offense to those who feel communism is great, but the fact is, history proves communism fails…it is impossible to have doctors and comic book cashiers make the same wage, it just does not work.)

1 comment:

  1. It's awsome hearing your thoughts on the pragmatic model because it gives me some things to think about as well. I have to say I kind of liked the pragmatic model because of the idea at how simple it is. People being compared to machines would make the world a lot less complex. Machines are easy to understand, if they brake something went wrong. A human is considered to be really complex and frankly thats what's annoying about us humans! I think sometimes if things were a bit more black and white like the pragmatic model, life would be easier. If one person didn't communicate, then we could sto all the drama and just handle it.

    ReplyDelete